Doing Theology in Today’s World: Modern vs. Postmodern Approaches

The shift from modern to postmodern thinking has reshaped theological discourse. While modernism emphasized certainty and reason, postmodernism questions absolute truth and prioritizes subjective experience. By balancing confidence in Scripture with humility, engaging in community, and focusing on essentials, Christians can effectively present biblical truth in today’s context.

The landscape of theological discourse has shifted dramatically in recent decades, requiring us to carefully consider how we present biblical truth in our current context. Let’s examine the key differences between modern and postmodern approaches to theology and how we can effectively communicate truth in today’s world.

The Modern Mindset

The modern era was characterized by an overly optimistic worldview that placed ultimate confidence in human reason and scientific progress. This approach to theology often emphasized:

The Postmodern Challenge

Today’s postmodern context presents unique challenges:

Biblical Response

Scripture provides wisdom for doing theology in any era:

Embrace Humility

“Do not be wise in your own eyes” (Prov 3:7)
“Whoever loves discipline loves knowledge” (Prov 12:1)
We must acknowledge our need for multiple counselors and advisors.

Maintain Clear Essentials

While engaging postmodern audiences, we must still clearly present the crucified and risen Savior and his gift of eternal life as the essential truth. The basic message remains unchanged – salvation through faith in Christ.

Balance Certainty and Mystery

Scripture teaches some things with absolute clarity while other matters require deeper study and reflection. We should be confident about clear biblical teaching while maintaining appropriate humility about complex theological issues.

Community Engagement

American individualism often conflicts with the biblical model of seeking counsel and doing theology in community. We need to recover a more communal approach to theological reflection.

Practical Application

Present truth with both confidence and humility
Engage in irenic (peaceable) theological discussion rather than merely polemical (argumentative) debate
Focus on clearly communicating essential doctrines while allowing room for diversity on secondary issues
Build relationships and engage in dialogue rather than mere proclamation

The key is maintaining biblical fidelity while engaging our contemporary context with wisdom and grace. This requires understanding both modern and postmodern mindsets while remaining anchored in timeless biblical truth.

Note: Since the 1990s, there has been a development of the concept of “Post Postmodernism”. Definitions vary widely and the concept needs to mature more, but it seems we are in a transition period at the time of the writing of this blog post.

Share the Post:

A group of people are sitting around a table with a book open in front of them

The Role of Community and Advisors in Theological Thinking

Theological thinking flourishes in community, where diverse perspectives and counsel enrich our understanding of Scripture. While individualism often isolates us, Scripture emphasizes the value of advisors and shared learning. By engaging with historical theology, participating in learning communities, and embracing multiple sources, we grow in wisdom and theological maturity.

A small group of friends studying the Bible together at a kitchen table, notebooks and coffee cups around, fellowship, learning, the joy of shared faith in a warm home setting

Essential vs. Non-Essential Doctrines: Finding Unity in Diversity

Distinguishing between essential and non-essential doctrines is vital for maintaining unity in the Body of Christ. Essential doctrines, like salvation through faith in Christ, form the foundation of Christian faith, while non-essential matters allow for diversity. By holding firmly to core truths and showing grace in secondary issues, believers can uphold theological integrity and foster unity.