Historical Theology: Learning from the Saints While Honoring Scripture

Man reading the Bible in his study with ethereal smoke encircling his head
Historical Theology represents a crucial approach to understanding Christian truth by examining how past believers interpreted and applied Scripture throughout church history. This discipline examines specific periods of Church history to understand the theology that developed during particular time periods, such as Patristic, Medieval, and Reformation eras.

While tradition is one of the easiest and most accessible ways to acquire information, we must remember that Scripture alone remains our primary and infallible source for truth – the principle known as Sola Scriptura. This balance is crucial for proper theological understanding.

Consider these key benefits of Historical Theology:

  • It prevents us from repeating past theological errors
  • It provides tested answers to perennial questions
  • It demonstrates how doctrine developed in response to challenges
  • It connects us to the broader Christian community across time

The Apostles’ Creed serves as an example of Historical Theology’s value. This ancient confession shows how early Christians summarized essential beliefs, providing a foundation that still guides believers today.

Avoiding the Tradition Trap

We must carefully weigh all traditional interpretations against Scripture itself. Some Christians have “surrendered one of the greatest convictions of the Reformation, namely, the supremacy of an appeal to Scripture over against the tradition of the church”. While respecting tradition, we must avoid traditionalism that might contradict biblical truth.

The Danger of Tradition

History shows us that the majority position isn’t always correct. Even after the Reformation, certain biblical truths like justification by faith alone have rarely been the majority position in church history. This reminds us to carefully weigh all traditional interpretations against Scripture itself.

Being Berean-Minded

Like the noble Bereans who “searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so” (Acts 17:11), we must approach Historical Theology with both respect and discernment. The Bible teaches that the majority can be incorrect – just as only Joshua and Caleb stood firm among the spies, we too must be willing to stand against popular tradition when it contradicts Scripture.

The Balance

This approach allows us to construct a biblical worldview that makes our Christian witness relevant to all people in need. We must maintain a healthy respect for tradition while avoiding traditionalism that might contradict biblical truth. The goal is to develop a Christian mind that can think through life’s most important issues while keeping Scripture as our final arbiter of truth.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

A group of people are sitting around a table with a book open in front of them

The Role of Community and Advisors in Theological Thinking

Theological thinking flourishes in community, where diverse perspectives and counsel enrich our understanding of Scripture. While individualism often isolates us, Scripture emphasizes the value of advisors and shared learning. By engaging with historical theology, participating in learning communities, and embracing multiple sources, we grow in wisdom and theological maturity.

Read More
Group of friends sitting in a cafe having Bible study reading the Holy Scriptures.

Doing Theology in Today’s World: Modern vs. Postmodern Approaches

The shift from modern to postmodern thinking has reshaped theological discourse. While modernism emphasized certainty and reason, postmodernism questions absolute truth and prioritizes subjective experience. By balancing confidence in Scripture with humility, engaging in community, and focusing on essentials, Christians can effectively present biblical truth in today’s context.

Read More